You Will Shoot Your Eye Out

The 1899/1900 FN Browning

by Ed Buffaloe

Historical Perspective

Guncotton, or nitrocellulose, made by dipping cotton in a mixture of nitric and sulfuric acids, was patented in 1846 by a Swiss chemist by the name of Christian Friedrich Schönbein, based on earlier work by French chemists Henry Braconnot and Théophile-Jules Pelouze.
Guncotton is highly flammable and chemically unstable, so early efforts to utilize it as a gunpowder ingredient or explosive caused some serious disasters.
But in 1884 the French chemist Paul Marie Eugène Vieille found a way to stabilize it.  He called his invention poudre blanche, or white powder, to distinguish it from traditional black gunpowder.
It burns much faster than black powder and produces comparatively little smoke, so it quickly became known as “smokeless” powder.
A number of attempts to create a self-loading (automatic) weapon were made prior to the invention of smokeless powder, including a gas-operated revolver made by Orbea Hermanos of Eibar, Spain as early as 1863.
None of these efforts were ultimately viable because of the heavy residues left by black powder, which inhibits mechanical functioning very quickly.
But immediately after the invention of smokeless powder, a number of people began serious work on designs for self-loading guns.
The most significant successful designs (other than John Browning’s) were those by Mannlicher, Bergmann, and Mauser.  Most of these early self-loading pistols had limited sales and/or were intended primarily for military use.
John Moses Browning (1855-1926) grew up in his father’s gun shop and learned to repair guns before he learned to read and write.
He filed his first firearm patent in 1879 at the age of 24.  Browning began experimenting with self-loading weapon designs around 1889.
He filed a patent on a gas-operated machine gun on 6 January 1890, and followed it with another dozen or so patents over the next decade on various types of self-loading weapons, both gas and recoil operated.
By 1894 Browning had completed his first prototype automatic pistol.  In 1895 the Colt’s Patent Fire Arms Manufacturing Company began producing Browning’s machine gun, which marked the beginning of a long collaboration between John Browning and the Colt’s Company.
On 24 July 1896 Browning signed a contract giving Colt’s the right to manufacture four of his automatic pistol designs for distribution in the U.S. and Canada.  However, Colt’s was almost certainly acquiring the rights in order to protect sales of their revolvers.
There was, as yet, no established market for self-loading pistols in the U.S.

An early Model 1900 FN Browning Pistol Photograph courtesy of John-Paul Attwood

Browning’s first pistol patent was filed on 14 September 1895 and was followed just over a year later by three pistol patents filed on 31 October 1896.  All four U.S. patents were granted on 20 April 1897 and given successive numbers:

• 580,923, for a gas-operated automatic pistol that was never manufactured, but various elements of which appeared in later Browning pistols–particularly the disconnector;
• 580,924, for a recoil-operated locked-breech design which became the Colt Automatic Pistol of 1900;
• 580,925, for a gas-operated automatic pistol with a rotating barrel locked-breech design and a grip safety, which was never manufactured;
• 580,926, for a recoil-operated blowback design which was an early prototype for the 1899/1900 FN Browning.

Browning was granted U.S. patent 621,747 on 21 March 1899, covering the final design for the 1899/1900 FN Browning.
Connecticut had been an early center for the manufacture of brass hardware, clocks, and firearms–and later of machine tools, gauges, bicycles, sewing machines, and all manner of precision mechanical devices.
Firearms manufacture was particularly centered in Hartford and New Haven, which both had rivers to provide power for machinery.
In the late nineteenth century Connecticut, and the Colt’s factory at Hartford in particular, was a major center for the dissemination of information and knowhow on the manufacture of interchangeable parts, which had become known in Europe as “the American System” of manufacture.
So it was that in 1897 Fabrique Nationale of Liège, Belgium sent their Director of External Affairs, Hart O. Berg, to his hometown of Hartford, Connecticut to investigate the latest U.S. techniques of bicycle manufacture.
FN had a large factory full of machine tools and skilled workers, but due to a change in ownership most of their military contracts had been lost to German concerns, so the company was looking for new products to keep them afloat.
John M. Browning was in Hartford at the same time to visit Colt’s.  Exactly how the two men met is probably unknown.
It may have been a chance encounter, or perhaps they were introduced by a mutual acquaintance.  But somehow Berg and Browning struck up a friendship, and Browning showed Berg his prototype for a .32 caliber self-loading pistol.
Colt’s had contracted the previous year to manufacture Browning’s handgun designs in the U.S., but actual production was still a long way off, and in any case Colt’s had not purchased Browning’s blowback-operated designs, preferring instead to concentrate on locked-breech guns that would be suitable for military applications.
Browning must have leapt at the opportunity to have his gun manufactured in Europe, while Berg’s mission to Connecticut achieved its goal of finding a viable product for his company to produce.
Browning’s prototype gun, and the ammunition for it, went to Belgium with Berg, and he and the FN engineers were astonished when it fired 500 rounds without a single failure to feed or eject.
There probably wasn’t another self-loading pistol in the world as reliable as John Browning’s.  Browning signed a contract with FN on 17 July 1897 to manufacture and sell the pistol in most of Europe.
The contract specifically forbade the sale of the gun in the U.S. and Canada, where Colt’s had the right to sell Browning’s designs, which is probably the main reason these guns are relatively scarce in the U.S. today, especially the Model 1899.
Hart Berg travelled to Ogden, Utah in January of 1898 to try to convice John Browning to come to Belgium and supervise the tooling-up process for manufacturing the pistol.
But Browning was in the most creative phase of his life and had other priorities.  Instead, he gave Berg his recommendations on how he thought the pistol could be most efficiently produced.*
FN began tooling up immediately, and the first prototypes were ready for testing by July.  The first production guns went on sale in January of 1899.
The 7.65mm Browning Cartridge
According to W.H.B. Smith, the 7.65mm Browning (.32 auto) cartridge was developed from the 8mm Bergmann Simplex cartridge, however this seems unlikely since the Simplex probably didn’t appear until at least 1900.
Hogg & Walter state it didn’t appear until 1902, in which case the Simplex cartridge might just as well be based on the Browning.
The Bergmann cartridge had a slightly tapered case that was about 5 thousandths of an inch longer than the Browning, and a bullet of nearly identical weight, though the Simplex cartridge generated a lower muzzle velocity.  Both guns were blowback-operated.
The Ammo Encyclopedia says the .32 auto cartridge was developed in 1897, the year of the initial patent.
Henry White and Burton Munhall in their book Pistol and Revolver Cartridges state:  “Recent research leads us to believe that the cartridge may have been developed experimentally in this country, although it was first introduced in Belgium in 1900 [sic] by Fabrique Nationale with the advent of the Browning Automatic Pistol.
We know that Browning patented his gun in 1897 and that for the next few years considerable work was done by various American companies on cartridges for his weapon.”
They cite a .32 Browning Automatic cartridge that was listed in the Winchester Repeating Arms Company catalog for August 1899.  They examined one of these cartridges which was headstamped “W.R.A.Co. .32 B.A.” and had a soft lead bullet.
John Malloy, in his article “Early Auto Pistol Cartridges,” doubts that Browning ever had the opportunity to examine a Bergmann Simplex cartridge.  He establishes that Browning had a longstanding relationship with Winchester, that the Browning brothers’ store carried Winchester cartridges, a number of which were in .32 caliber, and that Browning’s machine guns were all made to shoot existing rimmed rifle cartridges.
Malloy believes that Browning started with an existing .32 cartridge:  “It seems plausible that Browning shortened some of these [cartridges] to a case length he felt to be suitable for a magazine inside the grip.
He would then have reduced the rim until the cartridges fed smoothly over each other, leaving a slight flange to position the round in the chamber.  The semi-rimmed pistol cartridge was probably born in this manner.”   Anthony Vanderlinden, in FN Browning Pistols, Sidearms that Shaped World History,  reproduces a photograph of a box of 7.65mm FN cartridges that clearly shows a drawing of a Model 1899 pistol on the label.  FN 7.65mm cartridges were available for sale when the pistol went on the market in January of 1899.
 

The Model of 1899

Model 1899, s/n 156 Photograph courtesy of Bob Adams

The original FN Browning pistol was simply known as le Pistolet Browning, or the Browning Pistol.  When the Model 1900 appeared, the 1899 version was referred to by FN as the modèle de pré-série, or pre- series model.  When the 1910 FN Browning appeared, the Models 1899/1900 were often referred to as the “old model Browning.”  Only much later, as John M. Browning produced more and more designs, did year model designations become commonplace.  According to Vanderlinden, the Model 1899 has an overall length of 158mm (6.2 inches) and a barrel length of 100mm (3.9 inches).  It’s height is approximately 112mm (4.4 inches).  The magazine holds seven rounds.The Model 1899 is a striker-fired weapon which consists of a frame with a barrel screwed into it, a slide, and a separate breech block.  It was the first pistol ever to have a reciprocating slide as opposed to a reciprocating breech block or bolt.  The slide fits onto the frame from the front, while the breech block is inserted from the rear; the two are joined by two large screws.  The lower front portion of the slide completely surrounds the barrel, behind which is the attached breech block, slotted into the rear of the frame.  The upper portion of the slide consists of a tunnel enclosing the recoil spring, which does double duty as the striker spring.  There is an ejection port on the right side of the frame.  The extractor is a piece of spring steel with a hook on the end.
The gun features a stirrup-shaped connector bar, the two sides of which run from the trigger to the sear on either side of the magazine.  The sear is tensioned by a leaf spring in the grip of the gun, behind the magazine.  The manual safety blocks the sear and locks the trigger.  There is no provision for locking the slide open for cleaning.  Due to the weight of the slide and breech block, the gun has remarkably little felt recoil.  Its fixed barrel and precision manufacture (à la FN) make it extremely accurate.

Patent Drawing – U.S. Patent 621,747

By today’s standards the spring-above-the-barrel design is unusual.  However, the gun was the first truly successful commercial self-loading pistol, and as such its design was widely emulated in its day (e.g., the Pieper Bayard, the Clement, the Frommer Stop, the 1911 Melior, the Langenhan, the Owa, the 1908 Steyr Pieper, the Helfricht, the 1913 Smith & Wesson .35, and much later the .22 caliber Smith & Wesson Escort).  The ejector and ejection port were also widely copied.  John Browning already had simpler designs in his head, but he clearly wanted someone to make this one, probably because it worked so well.In 1899 the Belgian army was looking for a self-loading pistol.  They tested all the pistols of the era:  the Mauser, the Bergmann, the Roth (I presume this was a prototype Roth-Steyr), the Mannlicher, the Borchardt, and the Borchardt-Luger.  Probably immediately after the first Belgian army pistol trials FN decided to make a larger version of the M1899.  I’m guessing the little pistol looked positively diminutive next to the other guns in the trials, and FN thought it might be better received if it were larger.  The larger version had an extended grip, frame, and slide.  According to Vanderlinden, its overall length was 184mm (7 .25 inches), its barrel length was 122mm (4.8 inches), and it held 8 rounds instead of 7.  Only a very small number of these large models were made.  Gangarosa incorrectly gives the measurements and capacity of the large test model in place of those for the Model 1899.  The large gun was entered into subsequent Belgian military trials toward the middle of 1899.  The standard model and the large model were both entered in the British military trials in December of 1900, but were rejected due to the inadequate power of the 7.65mm Browning cartridge.

Model 1899, s/n 156 Photograph courtesy of Bob Adams

The smaller Browning was ultimately chosen as the standard pistol for the Belgian military.  However, a number of changes were requested for the military contract.  When these changes were incorporated the new gun became what we call today the Model 1900 FN Browning.  Initially FN thought they would continue to produce the Model 1899 for commercial sale, making the Model 1900 for military use only, and indeed virtually all of the first year’s production of the Model 1900 went toward fulfilling the military contract.  But FN quickly realized it was much more efficient to produce a single model, so the Model 1899 was phased out before the end of 1901.  Over 14,400 Model 1899 pistols are estimated to have been produced between 1899 and 1901.  They are rarely seen in the U.S.One of the distinctive features of these pistols is the reinforced area of the frame above the trigger guard, which is made of thicker steel than the rest of the frame.  On the Model 1899, this area extends just beyond the middle of the trigger guard (to the top front of the trigger itself), and the rear line of this reinforced area slants toward the front of the gun.  This reinforced area of the frame is marked on the left side Breveté S.G.D.G. (indicating the gun is patented), and is stamped with an oval cartouche featuring an image of the gun with a small FN monogram beneath it.  Some early safety levers have a round grip area with three concentric circles, while others are checkered.  There are no markings to indicate which position is ‘Fire’ and which is ‘Safe.’
The hard rubber grip plates feature an oval cartouche at the top with a picture of the gun and the FN monogram.  Beneath the oval, the grip plates are checkered.  The grip plates are quite thin and small, leaving several millimeters of steel grip area on the sides.  There is 4 or 5 millimeters of metal grip uncovered beneath the bottom of the grip plates.  The grip plates are held on by a large round plate in the rear with a threaded stud protruding through the grip plate onto which is screwed a slotted nut.
Slide legends are roll stamped on the left side.  There are two legends found:  FABRIQUE NATIONALE HERSTAL LIEGE and FABRIQUE NATIONALE HERSTAL LIEGE (BROWNING’S PATENT).  Apparently, these were interchangeable and both legends appear throughout production of the gun.  The slides, frames, and breech blocks are all proofed with the Liege Perron and an inspector’s proof, typically a star over a letter.  Serial numbers are stamped on the right side of the frame, just in front of the ejection port, and are also stamped on the right side of the slide and breech block.  Serial numbers started at 1 and ran to 9999, after which they ran from A1 to A4500 (approximately).
The finish was rust blue, with a fire blued trigger.  Nickel plating was an option, but few specimens are known with factory nickel.  No engraving was offered for the M1899.  Only a single fancy engraved model is known from the production era–a gun presented by FN to Theodore Roosevelt.
The Model of 1900

Model 1900 FN Browning with non-original grips

The Belgian Military requested that their gun have its frame more heavily reinforced than the Model 1899, be provided with larger, thicker grip plates, and have a lanyard at the base of the grip.  They also insisted that the safety positions be marked ‘Sur’ and ‘Feu’ (On and Fire).  Markings in German and English were available by special order for sale in other countries.  A cocking indicator was added by extending the top of the cocking lever so that it blocks the sight picture when the gun is not cocked.  Hence, it is possible to determine visually, or by feel, if the gun is cocked.  According to Vanderlinden, the Model 1900 is 164mm in length (though I measure mine at 162mm), and the barrel is 102mm long (though I measure mine at 100mm).  The frames were hand ground by machinists, and so may vary slightly in shape and length.  The reinforced portion of the frame above the trigger guard extends all the way to the rear of the trigger guard, and all the way to the ejection port on the right side; this area was also made several thousandths of an inch thicker on the Model 1899.  The rear line of the reinforced area is at right angles to the top of the frame.  The shape of the grip tang is slightly altered, as is the top of the breech block that forms the rear sight.  The circular grip area on the safety lever is checkered. The safety lever also serves to lock the slide open if engaged when the slide is all the way to the rear.The grip plates are thicker than those on the M1899 and extend almost to the edges of the grip frame.  Some early military contract guns were delivered with plain checkered grip plates that did not feature the oval cartouche at the top–these are quite scarce today.  Many of these grips were later replaced by plain checkered wooden grips, which are also quite scarce today.  The commercial grip plates continued to have the oval cartouche at the top with a picture of the gun and the FN monogram until 1905.  The left grip plate has a cutout on one corner where it abuts the lanyard.  At around serial number 200,000 the grip design was changed–the grips were slightly smaller (leaving a couple of millimeters of grip frame showing around their edges) and the oval cartouche contained only the large FN monogram.  The grip plates are retained by a rectangular backplate that fits across the grip frame behind them, and are held in place by a screw..
The gun continued to be referred to as le Pistolet Browning.  Markings were as follows:

• Guns made prior to 1907 were marked, on the left side of the slide, FABRIQUE NATIONALE HERSTAL LIEGE (BROWNING’S PATENT) in sans-serif characters or FABRIQUE-NATIONALE HERSTAL LIEGE (BROWNING’S PATENT) in serif characters.  The reinforced area of the frame above the trigger guard was marked on the left side with the roll-stamped cartouche containing a picture of the gun with the FN monogram beneath it and either BREVETE S.G.D.G. or BREVETÉ-S.G.D.G.–the characters on the frame matching those on the slide.  The frame, slide, and breech block were proofed with the Liege Perron and an inspector’s proof, consisting of a star over a letter.  Later the smokeless powder proof, a lion over the letters ‘PV’ was added.  A crown with two letters may appear on some guns–these are state arsenal acceptance proofs.  The serial number was stamped on the right side of the frame, slide, and breech block.
• After May of 1907 guns were marked in serif letters on the left side of the slide FABRIQUE-NATIONALE- D’ARMESdeGUERRE. HERSTAL-BELGIQUE.  We have also observed examples with the same inscription in sans-serif characters.  The reinforced area of the frame above the trigger guard featured the oval cartouche, as above, and was marked BROWNING’S PATENT over BREVETTE S.G.D.G.  The proofs were applied as above, as were serial numbers.

For details on serial numbers, please refer to Anthony Vanderlinden’s book.  He states that:  “Production of the first commercial pistols was erratic and large gaps exist in the early serial number ranges.”  Serial numbers began at 1, but many early pistols failed proof testing and were never completed.  A total of approximately 724,550 M1900 pistols were manufactured.  Production ended at the beginning of World War I in 1914, though sales had been considerably reduced by the introduction of the Model 1910, which went into production in 1912.  The success of the M1899/1900 may have forced the Colt’s company to begin the manufacture of the first Colt Automatic Pistol in 1900.
The finish of the M1900 was in rust blue or nickel plate.  Early pistols had fire blued triggers like those on the Model 1899.  Six different levels of engraving and gold inlay were available, as were mother-of-pearl and ivory grip plates.  Nickeled pistols were given a black undercoat before plating, and the trigger, safety, and screws were left with this black finish.  If the plating is worn off, the black undercoat should show through beneath it.
For many years almost every article you read about the Model 1900 stated that it had been the gun used to assassinate Archduke Franz Ferdinand, starting World War I.  The actual gun used was a Model 1910 FN Browning, but at the time the Model 1910 had only been out for 2 years and year model designations had not yet been adopted.  The press reported that the assassination was performed with a Browning pistol, and the M1900 was the Browning pistol most of the world was familiar with, so it was simply assumed to have been the gun used and the error was perpetuated for decades.
The Model 1900 saw wide distribution throughout Europe.  The Belgian war ministry placed an order for 10,000 guns in 1900, and it served as the standard sidearm for the Belgian military through World War I.  The Austro-Hungarian empire also purchased the weapon; the exact quantity purchased is not known, but Vanderlinden states that 770 were in the military inventory of 1914.  The gun was also widely used by German police.  Don Maus has documented at least 62 Model 1900 FN pistols with German police markings.  Many of these guns have safety markings in German, indicating that they were purchased under contract.  The Model 1900 also saw use by police in Finland, as well as during various wars up to 1945.  See Vanderlinden for details.
Disassembly

Model 1900 FN Browning disassembled

I call this section “Disassembly” rather than “Field Stripping” because the M1899 and M1900 require a screwdriver to disassemble, so the procedure is not normally done in the field.  Nevertheless, it is relatively simple.

1. Remove the magazine.
2. Draw the slide back and make sure the chamber is empty.
3. Release the slide and pull the trigger.
4. Unscrew the breech block screws and remove them.
5. Draw the slide forward off the frame.  (Note:  These guns are very tightly fitted.  The slide and breech block may not separate easily.  If this is the case, draw the slide back and lock it open with the manual safety latch.  Then release the safety, while holding your hand in front of the gun to catch the slide as it is propelled off the frame.)
6. Pull the recoil spring forward slightly and lift it away from its stop.
7. Remove the breech block (with attached spring and guide) from the rear of the frame.

When reinserting the breech block into the frame, pull the trigger to lower the sear.
Field Test
I finally found a Model 1900 FN Browning at a reasonable price–it has been reblued and doesn’t have the original grips, but the serial numbers match and it is fully functional.  For a few years I had only seen them in pictures, and the actual gun was smaller than I had imagined from seeing them in photographs.  The angle of the grip to the slide is about 10 degrees greater than perpendicular.  Most modern guns have a grip angled a little more–about 15 degrees greater than perpendicular–which enables them to be pointed more naturally.  Nevertheless, the M1900 feels good in my hand.  I can get two fingers around the grip strap and my little finger wraps around the bottom of the grip quite naturally.
I was astonished when four of the bullets from my first magazine went into the same hole (at about 25 feet)–if I were a better shot I believe I could shoot out the bullseye with this gun.  The M1900 digested every kind of ammunition I put through it and never once failed to feed or eject.  It is no wonder that it was an immediate success.

Comparing the Model 1899 and Model 1900 Browning Pistols

Copyright 2009 by Ed Buffaloe.  All rights reserved.
Click most small photographs to open a larger version in a new window, & to see additional photographs.